If A Tree Falls In The Forest...

As a topic prompt, this week we are supposed to respond to our professor's blog post, How Seriously Do We Take Jesus’ Words in John 17:23 On The Need For Christian Unity?

Before we get to this passage in John 17, unity and oneness have been a frequent theme in John’s Gospel (Seeà John 10:16, 38; 11:52; 14:10-11, 20, 23; and 15:4-5). Allow me to quote the last reference,

Grapevine in Israel. Photo Greg Dueker

Abide in me, and I in you. As the branch cannot bear fruit by itself, unless it abides in the vine, neither can you, unless you abide in me. I am the vine; you are the branches. Whoever abides in me and I in him, he it is that bears much fruit, for apart from me you can do nothing. (John 15:4-5)

Now in chapter 17:22-23, we read,

The glory that you have given me I have given to them, that they may be one even as we are one, I in them and you in me, that they may become perfectly one, so that the world may know that you sent me and loved them even as you loved me.

I love this prayer. Obviously this unity Jesus speaks of was important to him since it was on his mind right before he went to his death on the cross. Should it be important to us? Of course! However I wonder in what way it should be important.

Should it be important because it is something we are supposed to produce? I have to confess that sounds kind of arrogant and self-important to me especially since Jesus was actually praying to the Father, not to us.  

Christian unity should it be important for another reason—because it is a sign of Christ’s presence in our lives. Unity is made possible by his re-gifting the glory, which the Father had given to him, to us. Unity is made perfect when we respond by giving all the glory back to him through loving and humbly serving others.

Now these verses in John 17 are from Jesus’ High-priestly prayer for his people. His petition to his Father on our behalf was both passionate and profound.

So was Jesus’ prayer not answered? This is a troublingly honest thought to be sure.

Since Jesus never spoke outside of what flowed from the heart of the Father I will assume that the answer wasn’t “No.” Perhaps some might say that it was answered with an eschatological, “Not yet.” While this makes a little more sense for once sin is completely removed from the world and the Kingdom of God is fully manifested, complete unity is an easy thing for us to picture. However, this might be too convenient for us, excusing us from serious determined efforts at unity if it can’t truly be achieved until the Millennial Kingdom. My dear friend, wrote passionately,

“We can hide behind claims that Christians are invisibly united through faith in Jesus Christ even in the midst of visible disunity. I seriously doubt that Jesus had in mind invisible unity that was somehow divorced from visible unity. Invisible unity must be visible; otherwise, it is illusory.”

While I think I have come to share The Metzger’s passion for unity, I think that his last statement reaches too far. “Illusory” is a word for used things that are not real, that are based on an illusion. Visibility has not been a metric by which reality is measured for a very long time…except in Missouri (the “Show Me” State). Despite believing in many things we cannot see (like air), we live in a culture that too often fails to recognize the reality of the spiritual realm. As Christians we should not fall into the same error. Invisible is not the same as unreal.

I contend that we are already one spiritually if we are truly Christ’s…whether we recognize it or not. There is a spiritual unity that may or may not be seen—that flies in the face of such rationalistic statements as “Invisible unity must be visible; otherwise, it is illusory” because they are not relational enough. Is our unity in what we do or in whose we are and whom we depend on for our salvation? When abiding people meet there is no hiding the unity of the Spirit.

Allow me to wax momentarily metaphorical. This is Portland, so consider a tree…, is it one or is it many? It may sound like a stupid question, but the answer may depend on how we are looking at the tree. There are many individual leaves that while similar all have their own distinctives and character. There are many branches and twigs leading to those leaves, each with their seemingly random angle, thickness and length. While each branch, twig, and leaf is separate and unique, when we step back from hugging it and widen our scope to “look larger” we see that the many elements really form one tree, each part in its place fulfilling its purpose. So are the leaves many or one? Many, if you don’t believe me look at my front lawn in the fall. Yet in a very real sense, as part of the tree the many are one. I use this analogy with caution, as an illustration of how we may be looking too small when we look for unity.  

Am I simply making excuses and contending for an invisible unity? Well that depends on how big we choose to look. Are we focused in too closely on what is in our hands to see the unity that actually exists? Has our vision become pixilated like when you stand too close to the huge TVs in Costco? Sometimes you have to step back and look again. Are we individual buildings or a city? Again, I contend for the possibility that the visibility of unity depends upon the scope of our gaze.

Perfect unity exists now in the lives of those who have surrendered pursuing their own glory and maintaining their own kingdom. It is found in the indwelling of Christ and the Father by the Spirit. It is not something we could ever produce on our own. What I love is meeting another who is united to Christ and sensing immediately the unity of the Spirit. Certainly this spiritual unity manifests visibly. I think we just need eyes to recognize it.

I recently attended an ecumenical luncheon of sorts arranged by a custodian at our church. He grew up in the Lutheran Church and still is an active Lutheran while working at a Foursquare Church. Somehow his life was touched by the love of Christ through those he served with and he wanted to share his gratitude with us by inviting us to eat a great lunch and by allowing us the opportunity to sit in open fellowship with pastors and others from the two Lutheran churches he has attended. Wonderful people, all part of God’s unified plan to touch one man’s life, and also a part of the tapestry of Christian unity.

What are some of the visible signs of the presence of biblical unity that is synonymous with our remaining in Christ? We don’t shrivel up in the heat of circumstances. We are not prone to separate from his purposes. We humbly accept correction and pruning. Our lives produce good fruit in God’s eyes and a wholesome witness takes place in the eyes of the watching world.  

Psalm 133 

¹ Behold, how good and pleasant it is
    when brothers dwell in unity!
² It is like the precious oil on the head,
    running down on the beard,
on the beard of Aaron,
    running down on the collar of his robes!
³ It is like the dew of Hermon,
    which falls on the mountains of Zion!
For there the Lord has commanded the blessing,
    life forevermore.